Skip to content
$5.95 FLAT RATE SHIPPING ALL US ORDERS
Store
Store
Shop All Products
Pre-Orders & New Releases
New Items
Bundle & Save
Non-Polyvinyl Shop
Shop All Merch
Clothing
Goods
Books
Drinkware
Buttons/Stickers/Pins
Posters/Wall Art
Non-Polyvinyl Shop
All Music
All Merch
Best Sellers
New Arrivals
Fresh Restocks
Shop All Music
Vinyl
CDs
Tapes
Digital
Shop Featured Items
Limited Edition Vinyl
PV Music & Merch
PV Classics
Emo Essentials
Double Double Whammy
Father/Daughter Records
Keeled Scales
American Football - LP1 25th Anniversary Edition + (Covers)
Cap'n Jazz - Shmap'n Shmazz
The Get Up Kids - STWHA (25th Anniversary Edition)
Hum - The Reissues
Artists
Artists
A-E
alexalone
Alvvays
American Football
Anamanaguchi
Antarctigo Vespucci
Bachelor
Birthmark
Charlotte Cornfield
Chris Farren
F-J
Fred Thomas
Generationals
The Get Up Kids
Good Morning
Grapetooth
IAN SWEET
Jay Som
Jeff Rosenstock
Julia Jacklin
K-O
Kero Kero Bonito
Laura Jane Grace
LIES
MAN ON MAN
Momma
Oceanator
of Montreal
Owen
P-Z
Palehound
Pedro The Lion
Plato III
Squirrel Flower
STRFKR
Rodrigo Amarante
Xiu Xiu
Yumi Zouma
Full Roster
News
Tours
About
About
Contact
Our Story
History
Meet the Team
Polyvinyl Family
Enter Search Keyword
Enter Search Keywords
Enter Search Keywords
View my cart (0)
0
View my cart (0)
0
Enter Search Keywords
Enter Search Keywords
Store
Store
Shop All Products
Pre-Orders & New Releases
New Items
Bundle & Save
Non-Polyvinyl Shop
Shop All Merch
Clothing
Goods
Books
Drinkware
Buttons/Stickers/Pins
Posters/Wall Art
Non-Polyvinyl Shop
All Music
All Merch
Best Sellers
New Arrivals
Fresh Restocks
Shop All Music
Vinyl
CDs
Tapes
Digital
Shop Featured Items
Limited Edition Vinyl
PV Music & Merch
PV Classics
Emo Essentials
Double Double Whammy
Father/Daughter Records
Keeled Scales
Artists
Artists
A-E
alexalone
Alvvays
American Football
Anamanaguchi
Antarctigo Vespucci
Bachelor
Birthmark
Charlotte Cornfield
Chris Farren
F-J
Fred Thomas
Generationals
The Get Up Kids
Good Morning
Grapetooth
IAN SWEET
Jay Som
Jeff Rosenstock
Julia Jacklin
K-O
Kero Kero Bonito
Laura Jane Grace
LIES
MAN ON MAN
Momma
Oceanator
of Montreal
Owen
P-Z
Palehound
Pedro The Lion
Plato III
Squirrel Flower
STRFKR
Rodrigo Amarante
Xiu Xiu
Yumi Zouma
News
Tours
About
About
Contact
Our Story
History
Meet the Team
Polyvinyl Family
American Football - LP1 25th Anniversary Edition + (Covers)
Cap'n Jazz - Shmap'n Shmazz
The Get Up Kids - STWHA (25th Anniversary Edition)
Hum - The Reissues
Help
Login
Your cart
Keep Shopping
Your cart is empty.
Let's fix that!
New Items
Bundles
Vinyl
Merch
Item added to your cart
Checkout
Continue shopping
Search
Enter Search Keywords
Enter Search Keywords
Filters
Filters
Artist
(0)
Select...
Make Believe
Various Artists
Product Type
(0)
CD
Digital
Vinyl
Vinyl
(0)
7"
12"
Year
(0)
Select...
2005
2006
Variant Status
(0)
Apply Filters
Filters
Artist
(0)
Select...
Make Believe
Various Artists
Product Type
(0)
CD
Digital
Vinyl
Vinyl
(0)
7"
12"
Year
(0)
Select...
2005
2006
Variant Status
(0)
3 items
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sort
Owen/Joan of Arc/Make Believe/Love of Everything
The Association of Utopian Hologram Swallowers
Digital
Format
Digital
Make Believe
Of Course
Format
Make Believe
Shock of Being
Format
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Latest Releases
Cap'n Jazz - Shmap'n Shmazz
American Football - American Football (25th Anniversary Edition)
The Get Up Kids - Something to Write Home About (25th Anniversary Deluxe Edition)
Latest Releases
Cap'n Jazz
Shmap'n Shmazz
Vinyl / Tape
American Football
American Football (25th Anniversary Edition)
Vinyl / Digital
The Get Up Kids
Something to Write Home About (25th Anniversary Deluxe Edition)
Vinyl / Digital
